Explore Nicky's most beloved dishes, crafted with care and tradition. From our unique Sicilian pies to comforting pasta, there's a favorite for everyone.
Sicilian Pie
Hand-Tossed Slice
Baked Ziti
Our thick, airy Sicilian crust, topped with rich sauce and fresh mozzarella, baked to golden perfection.
The classic New York slice, thin and crisp, made with our daily fresh dough and signature sauce.
Al dente ziti pasta baked with our slow-simmered marinara, creamy ricotta, and melted mozzarella cheese.
Fresh Dough, Slow-Simmered Marinara
We believe great food starts with great ingredients. Our dough is made fresh daily, stretched by hand, and our marinara is slow-simmered for hours to develop its rich, authentic flavor. Only whole-milk mozzarella makes the cut.
Italian Favorites for Every Craving
Hot Heroes
Classic Italian heroes, served hot on fresh bread with your choice of fillings. Perfect for a quick lunch.
Baked Ziti
Al dente ziti pasta baked with our slow-simmered marinara, creamy ricotta, and melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Parmesan
Tender chicken cutlets, breaded and fried, topped with our homemade marinara and melted mozzarella.
Whether it's a quick lunch slice or a full family dinner, Nicky's is ready. Order online for convenient pickup or local delivery right to your door on Mamaroneck Avenue.